facebook icontwitter Icon

Rodman Successfully Argues to Dismiss Claim against Town of Amherst

In the matter of Kemper Services Group a/s/o Carl Galante v. Town of Amherst, the petitioner was seeking a petition to file a late notice of claim against our client, Town of Amherst.

This claim was brought over a year after the date of the accident, and well over the 90 day time limit an individual has to notice a claim against a municipality. 

Petitioner argued there was no prejudice because the Town of Amherst had constructive and actual notice of the accident.  Petitioner did not provide any excuse to the untimely filing.

On behalf of the Town of Amherst, we opposed the petition insisting there was prejudice in allowing an untimely notice of claim to be filed, as it was unable to exercise its right to conduct a discovery hearing pursuant to Gen. Mun. Law 50-h.  Further, we used the decision in Tate v. State Univ. Const. Fund, 2017 NY Slip Op 05009 (4th Dep’t June 16, 2017) to successfully argue against petitioner’s petition.  In Tate, the Fourth Department found the plaintiff failed to demonstrate a reasonable excuse for his failure to serve the notice of claim within 90 days of the claim's accrual or within a reasonable time thereafter.

Here, the Court also found that without any reasonable excuse for the untimely filing and without the ability to engage in proper pre-discovery initiatives, there would be prejudice against the Town of Amherst, and dismissed and denied the petition to file a late notice of claim.

The opposition papers were authored and argued by Sarah N. Rodman.

Other News

Chmiel and Marriott Obtain Dismissal in Civil Suit Against Town of Amherst and a Police Officer

Chelus, Herdzik, Speyer & Monte, P.C. Welcomes New Associates

Josefiak and Kawalec Successful in Motion Dismissing Action against Client

Chmiel and Fiske Obtain Dismissal in Swimming Pool Accident Case

Loftus Successful at Trial

Monte and Marriott to Give Estate Planning Presentation

Loftus Successfully Argues Appeal at Fourth Department; Labor Law Case Dismissed

Loftus Successful with Summary Judgment Motion

Speyer and Renda Win Appeal, Securing Dismissal of Products Liability Action

New Associate Eric W. Marriott Joins Firm’s Municipal Law Group

Loftus Secures Dismissal of Case Against Contractor Under the Espinal Rule

Eric Marriott Joins the Firm of Chelus, Herdzik, Speyer & Monte, P.C.

Justina Potenzo Joins the Firm of Chelus, Herdzik, Speyer & Monte, P.C.

Chmiel Wins Appeal with Regard to an Automobile Accident Involving a Stranded Vehicle on Bridge

Chmiel and Josefiak Win on Appeal Regarding Assumption of Risk and Football

Firm Supports Special Hockey Tournament

Hedges Presents Trust Seminar at NBI CLE

Hriczko Successful on Motion to Dismiss

Michael M Chelus, Esq. and Richard J. Zielinski, Esq. Roll Out a Presentation on Motor Vehicle Litigation for the ECBA

Chmiel and Trank Present "Deposition Basics in Personal Injury Litigation" to Members of the Erie County Bar Association

Chmiel Wins Appeal, Affirming Dismissal of Case

Loftus Successful on Serious Injury Threshold Motion

Sign up for our
Email Newsletter

Read Current

Summing Up

Business Newsletter

Municipal Law Update


2448 Union Road

Cheektowaga, NY 14227


Map & Directions


Main Court Building at Lafayette Square

438 Main Street, Tenth Floor

Buffalo NY 14202

Map & Directions




fax: 716-852-0038

E-mail: mailbox@cheluslaw.com

Insurance Company Services

Appellate Advocacy

Environmental & Toxic Tort

Personal Injury Defense

Workers' Compensation

See More

Business Services

Collection of Receivables

Corporate Reorganization

Mergers and Acquisitions

Zoning and Land Use

See More

Personal/Family Services

Construction Accidents

Elder Law & Medicaid Planning

Federal and New York State

     Workers' Compensation Claims

Real Estate

See More

Municipal Law

Firematics Law Concerning Fire

    and Emergency Services

Tax Assessment Matters

Representation in Litigation

See More

Network Solutions Secure Site Seal

Legal Disclaimer

Attorney Advertising. All Content Copyright of Chelus, Herdzik, Speyer & Monte, P.C. 2012